Check Your Tech Policies
Putting Your Policies Into Action
There are so many reminders this Supreme Court case brings forth. Here are some of my thoughts and questions for you:
- When was the last time you, your HR consultant and/or your employment law attorney audited and updated your employee handbook to make sure you have everything you need to protect your organization? If it’s been more than 1-2 years, you’re way overdue!
- When was the last time your organization trained your managers on the organization’s expectations regarding implementing and enforcing policies? Considering this example of the problems a well-meaning manager created, what would your managers do or say in this situation?
- Considering how quickly technology is changing, read your computer, phone and company equipment policies to see whether you are protecting the organization at the level needed.
- If you have a policy allowing you to access all computer and telephone use, have you ever implemented this right? If so, did you document your actions, who conducted the research, what you discovered, and how you handled any concerns with the employee?
- I’ve received many calls from employers regarding employees inappropriately accessing Internet sites. We also are aware that some of our employees overuse our computers for non-offensive personal purposes during the workday (shopping, reading/writing personal emails, playing games, general surfing).
The real question is what are you and other managers in your organization doing about it?
Does everyone know who to contact to resolve these situations? Are managers acting independently and handling, mishandling or ignoring these situations? Is ignoring some of these inappropriate behaviors putting you at risk for harassment charges?
While I can certainly assist you with any of the above concerns, I encourage you to check your handbook, your policies, your practices and your managers’ understanding of their role regarding the increasingly sensitive area of technology in the workplace.
If you’re not
call Arlene today
I always include in the computer policy of my clients’ handbooks an “Our Right to Access Information” statement that employees should not assume privacy of any of the work they’ve created on company computers or on any of the communication that occurs on company equipment, including computers, phones, Internet or other information systems.
This month, the Supreme Court ruled on exactly this topic in a case between an employee and the City of Ontario, CA. Quon, a City employee, was apparently disciplined for sending personal and sexual text messages during work hours on a telephone paid for by the City. Quon claimed that the City’s review of his text messages was a violation of his Fourth Amendment rights and sued all the way up to the Supreme Court.
In a Gray Plant Mooty article, author Megan L. Anderson, stated that “The US Supreme Court…unanimously [upheld] a government employer’s search of employee text messages sent on employer-owned equipment as valid under the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.” She also wrote that the Supreme Court provided “a helpful reminder on the importance of a well-drafted, clearly communicated electronic communications policy, stating that such policies shape the reasonable expectations of employees when clearly communicated.”
The City had a solid written policy stating their right to search/access the employee’s text messages, yet the lawsuits continued.
City of Ontario employees were required to reimburse the City for any personal usage of the City phones assigned to them that exceeded the fees normally paid. Quon’s personal use of the phone messaging services exceeded the customary limit, so the City decided to audit some of his (and others’) text messages to see how much of the messaging was personal vs. business-related. That’s when they discovered the personal use during work hours and the sexual nature of the communications.
Of course, these cases are never simple. To compound the issue, Anderson’s article explains that, “a management-level police official had told Quon that his texts would not be audited if he paid the City for any charges incurred due to Quon exceeding the City’s monthly limit on text characters.” So the written policy was potentially compromised because a manager had misinformed the employee on how the policy was to be implemented.
Nonetheless, the Court ruled in the employer’s favor.
Copyright (c) 2010 Arlene Vernon, HRx, Inc.
Lessons for Employers
So what does this mean for us? Even though this ruling related to the public sector, it translates to the actions of all employers. Anderson continues by stating:
“Both public and private employers might minimize legal risks through the following steps:
- Employers should develop and clearly communicate to employees a well-written policy that covers all forms of electronic communications and emerging technology. This policy should clearly state that employees do not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in, and that the employer may monitor and review, any electronic communications, even if personal, that are sent, received, accessed, or stored on equipment or other items owned by, provided by, or paid for by the employer.
- Management should be trained to follow the official electronic communications policy and not to make statements or engage in practices inconsistent with that policy.
- In addition to communicating its electronic communications policy, employers should train employees on the policy and the employer’s expectations on appropriate usage of workplace technology.
- Employers should have legitimate business reasons for searching electronic communications of employees and should narrowly tailor such searches to the employer’s objectives and the unique circumstances at hand.”
Here’s a link to the complete article: http://www.gpmlaw.com/resources/newsletter
If I can help update you update your technology/communications policy or any other policies for you, give me a call!
Copyright (c) 2010 Arlene Vernon, HRx, Inc.
About Arlene Vernon
Arlene Vernon, PHR, partners with small businesses as their Human Resource Xpert to create their HR systems and solve their HR problems.
If you have gaps in your HR operation, have an employee problem to solve, or want to enhance your managers’ skills, call Arlene today. Learn
how HRx can save you time and help you avoid costly HR mistakes. HRx, Inc., 574 Prairie Center Drive #135/285, Eden Prairie, MN 55344, 952-996-0975,
HRx, Inc. respects your privacy and does not give out or sell subscriber names and/or e-mail addresses. Feel free to pass this newsletter to your
friends and colleagues as long as the entire newsletter is kept intact. If this newsletter has been forwarded to you, please
sign upto receive your own copy. If you wish to be taken off this list simply
send an email
Share This Article
This article is available for your use or reprinting in web sites or company communications with the agreement that Arlene’s biographical information above and a link to her website is included with the article.